
The All Blacks won’t lose “silly games” under Dave Rennie as they did during Scott Robertson’s tenure as head coach, according to former Springboks hooker Hanyani Shimange. New Zealand beat Scotland 43-21 at Murrayfield, a far more comprehensive result than their 25-17 narrow win over the Scots this time last year, when Damian McKenzie scored a late try to seal it.
In the Scottish capital, New Zealand kept the hosts scoreless in the second half and added three tries to their tally.
All Blacks won’t drop easy games like Scotland anymore
Scotland has long hoped to claim its first-ever victory over the All Blacks, who remain unbeaten at Murrayfield. Gregor Townsend’s side again fell short. Shimange believes there was a chance of an upset under Robertson, but not under Rennie.
“Under Dave Rennie, I don’t think they’ll drop like silly games. Whereas under Razor, I thought maybe there was a chance,” the former Stormers hooker said on the Verdict show, where he was joined by fellow ex-Boks Jean de Villiers and Schalk Burger.
“They won’t drop easy games, and I don’t think New Zealand necessarily played that well.”
Former flanker and World Rugby Player of the Year Burger disagreed that the All Blacks played poorly, but he was equally critical of the Scots.
“I think their second half was good because it was suffocating and they strangled them,” he said.
“They had those two tries straight off the bat. Then when they went up 36 points to 20, whatever it was, then they just kicked early in the set and pinned Scotland in their own half, and then obviously Scotland hung themselves.”
Gregor Townsend doesn’t have a plan B
Burger believes Scotland plays a similar brand of rugby to the All Blacks and lacks a alternative, which meant only one outcome was likely.
“If you look at the two 23s, Gregor Townsend wants to play high-pace Super Rugby against them, and you look at the All Blacks side, and you say, let’s go play high-pace Super Rugby – they were always going to win,” he said.
“That’s the issue that the Scottish side has. They’re a one-trick pony, but they don’t have the tools to actually go take the pace out of the game and sort of bully the All Blacks, or carry it close to the guts or kick a little bit earlier in the set. Force the All Blacks to exit outside their 22 for 10 minutes and let them just take the heat out of the game because the All Blacks will get frustrated and make some bad decisions, but because they just play high tempo, high tempo, quick throw, play around, the set phase, I think it’s always going to be one result, unfortunately.”
Shimange added that Townsend’s side is inconsistent in both performance and results.
“The best Scottish performance was the one against us at Loftus,” he said.
“I mean, they were cross-kick away from winning. Remember, it was Kyle Steyn who knocked it on; that’s probably the best game they’ve had, though. Again, when last did they win the Six Nations, they have these pockets of magic.”
What comes next
Scotland now turns its attention to its meeting with Eddie Jones’ Japan. Rennie’s All Blacks head to Cardiff, where they face Wales.