All Blacks squad: Five takeaways as injuries put depth under the ‘spotlight’ while Dave Rennie makes a ‘game-changing’ pick

Codie Taylor will once again captain the All Blacks in November, as head coach Dave Rennie and his fellow selectors, Sir Graham Henry and Neil Barnes, named a squad of 36 players for the northern leg of the Nations Championship. The tour includes matches against Scotland, Wales and England before the finals weekend. The squad is bigger than many predicted, and it includes several selection surprises.

Injuries stretch the squad

Despite the size of the group, the All Blacks have been hit hard by injuries. Samisoni Taukei’aho (calf), Shannon Frizell (knee), Tyrel Lomax (neck), Leroy Carter (ankle), Ruben Love (ankle), Ardie Savea (shoulder), Luke Jacobson (elbow), Caleb Clarke (shoulder), Ollie Norris (knee) and Billy Proctor (shoulder) are all sidelined. Simon Parker has also made himself unavailable for personal reasons.

Rennie has also left out Patrick Tuipulotu and Du’Plessis Kirifi, and he has overlooked several in-form players who shone during the NPC. The most notable omission is Tasman’s try-scoring machine Kyren Taumoefolau, who scored 19 tries in 11 appearances for Tasman.

The squad has a familiar feel. Taylor is joined by Asafo Aumua and George Bell as the hooker options. Ethan de Groot, George Bower, Xavier Numia, Fletcher Newell and Pasilio Tosi remain in the prop group, and uncapped tighthead Saula Ma’u comes in for Lomax. Scott Barrett, who returned against Australia, is named among the locks alongside Josh Lord, Fabian Holland and Tupou Vaa’i. Jamie Hannah earns his first All Blacks squad selection after serving as injury cover previously.

The loose forward stocks have thinned throughout the year, but Rennie still has a strong group of back-rowers. Anton Segner continues after his breakout year at the highest level. Peter Lakai and Wallace Sititi provide versatility in the loose trio, and Ethan Blackadder returns from the setback that kept him out of the two Tests against Australia.

Two players make their first appearance in the squad this year. Crusaders duo Leicester Fainga’anuku and Christian Lio-Willie earn the call-ups. Fainga’anuku missed Rugby’s Greatest Rivalry series and the July internationals due to injury, while Lio-Willie earns his first selection under Rennie after a two-year absence. He debuted under Scott Robertson in 2024.

The scrum-halves are the same three Rennie has used for most of the year: Cam Roigard, Kyle Preston and Cortez Ratima. Damian McKenzie is listed among the first-fives and will likely start against Scotland. Richie Mo’unga is fit again and should return against Wales or England. Josh Jacomb is the third fly-half option and could make his Test debut after featuring on the Rugby’s Greatest Rivalry tour.

There are no changes in the centres, where Jordie Barrett, Quinn Tupaea, Timoci Tavatavanawai and Anton Lienert-Brown all stay. Chay Fihaki is the headline outside back inclusion following Carter’s injury. He will compete with Will Jordan, Fehi Fineanganofo, Rieko Ioane and Josh Moorby for a spot on the wing, while Beauden Barrett is an option at full-back and first-five.

A game-changing selection

Last year, South Africa coach Rassie Erasmus debuted his hybrid experiment by naming Andre Esterhuizen on the bench against the Barbarians. Usually a midfielder, Esterhuizen has regularly played as a loose forward for the Springboks since then. The 32-year-old has become a regular bench option after struggling for Test caps behind Damian de Allende at inside centre.

South Africa are not the only team to try this approach. France have done something similar with Sekou Macalou and Oscar Jegou, and England have trained with Ben Earl and Henry Pollock in the backs.

Rennie is eager to follow suit with Fainga’anuku, based on his performances in the back row for the Crusaders during this year’s Super Rugby Pacific campaign. Fainga’anuku started the season in the backline, playing on the wing and in the centres, the positions where he began his career and earned his previous Test caps. However, he had his biggest impact in the loose forwards, and that is where he earned his recall.

Having played two halves of rugby for Tasman since returning from a broken leg, Fainga’anuku is set to return to the mix. Rennie’s decision could prove to be a game-changer for the All Blacks.

Erasmus popularised the 6-2 bench split, and many nations have copied it. New Zealand has been the exception. Only Ian Foster strayed from the traditional 5-3 split, in the record defeat to the Springboks in London before the 2023 Rugby World Cup. Because Fainga’anuku is a hybrid player, Rennie can select a 6-2 split that is essentially still a 5-3, which carries far less risk. The bench is becoming more influential in international rugby, and Fainga’anuku offers an edge in the final quarter. He provides impact in the back row and centres and can also cover the wing, which Esterhuizen cannot do.

A real test of the All Blacks’ depth

The loose forwards have been hit especially hard, with Savea and Jacobson ruled out. New Zealand managed the two Bledisloe Cup Tests without that duo. However, Frizell’s injury and Parker’s withdrawal add pressure to the back-row stocks. Lomax’s absence strains the front row further, and Tamaiti Williams has already missed the entire season. Taukei’aho’s calf injury opens a door for Bell, who suffered a setback of his own before the first whistle of Rugby’s Greatest Rivalry.

Mo’unga will miss the first Test against Scotland at the very least. McKenzie and Beauden Barrett combined well as playmakers against the Wallabies, but the tour is a different challenge, and the accumulation of injuries puts pressure on the entire squad.

Set-piece concerns

Rennie and his selectors have partly addressed the set-piece problems that the Springboks exposed during the Rugby’s Greatest Rivalry series. Lomax stays in New Zealand to manage his neck issue. He is a world-class tighthead when at his best, but he has not shown that form this year. His omission protects his health and the health of the All Blacks’ scrum.

The scrum was not a major factor in the Tests against the Wallabies, largely because both teams treated the set piece more as a way to restart play than as a weapon. Scotland and England have a different focus, particularly England. Steve Borthwick’s side may have endured its worst-ever Six Nations campaign, but its scrum was one of the few major positives. Scotland’s scrum is often underrated on the international stage, and both teams will look to pressure the All Blacks at scrum time.

The lineout was also an issue against South Africa, as Rennie’s side regularly threw to the front. Attacking from further back is easier, but New Zealand chose to avoid that risk and threw to where they felt they could win the ball. Scott Barrett’s return improved the lineout, but the Wallabies claimed multiple steals in both Tests. Gregor Townsend, Borthwick and Steve Tandy will all notice that, and each has strong lineout jumpers available.

Rewarding form

Some will question the absence of Lucas Casey, who impressed for Otago in the NPC, and Taumoefolau. Still, Rennie has found room to reward NPC form. Fihaki earned his debut as a last-minute replacement for the Sydney Bledisloe Cup Test, and he keeps his place largely through his NPC performances. Hannah has also muscled his way up the lock pecking order, which is no small feat given that Tuipulotu and Darry were both available for selection.

Lio-Willie’s recall addresses the need for an abrasive, physical back-rower, and Parker’s absence leaves room for him. The 28-year-old deserves this recall after narrowly missing out on the Rugby’s Greatest Rivalry tour.

Jacomb also keeps his place. He featured only in the latter stages of Taranaki’s NPC season, but he was excellent in South Africa when given the chance. Bell was superb for Canterbury and deserves another opportunity after injury kept him off the Rugby’s Greatest Rivalry tour.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *