All Blacks: Kieran Read laments the exclusion of a “world-class player” as Justin Marshall is left “baffled” by the bench selection

Former All Blacks Kieran Read and Justin Marshall have questioned some of head coach Dave Rennie’s selection choices, urging him to keep his starting side largely unchanged for Saturday’s Bledisloe Cup rematch with the Wallabies in Sydney. New Zealand cruised to a 50-19 win at Eden Park last weekend, retaining the Bledisloe Cup for the 24th successive year, but they had earlier suffered a 3-1 series defeat to the Springboks in Rugby’s Greatest Rivalry.

Consistency over change

Read, a former number eight, said the All Blacks should not make changes for the sake of it. “It’s a big call. I personally think we’re not in a position to make too many changes,” Read told The Good, The Bad & Rugby Australia & New Zealand podcast.

Read said the team needs to prove its progress on the field. “We haven’t shown that we can back it up yet, performances, it’s been that way for a few years. Dave Rennie has instilled a little bit of maybe extra optimism, confidence in us as fans, but we haven’t seen it. So, we need to go out there and put our best foot forward and show that we’ve made those improvements.”

He accepted that some changes are unavoidable. “Obviously there’s to be a few enforced ones with concussions and things. So, you make those changes, but I’d like to see a consistent team as much as we can.”

Marshall, a former scrum-half, agreed that Rennie cannot afford to experiment too much before the Nations Championship Tests against Scotland, Wales and England next month. “I just feel there’s still too much grey for us to be too experimental,” he said. He pointed out the limited time left in the schedule. “Ultimately come the end of this weekend, the All Blacks will be back in New Zealand. I think it’s the 18th of October. And then on the 7th of November, they’re playing Scotland without any more rugby, you know?”

Marshall also noted that injuries have already forced changes. Ethan Blackadder and Leroy Carter are out of the starting team through injury, he said, and the rest of the side should stay consistent. “You want to try and challenge that team to be consistent, backing up the performance, don’t you?”

Holland’s omission

Attention then turned to lock Fabian Holland, who has not featured in the All Blacks’ last two Tests. Holland started New Zealand’s first two Tests against the Springboks in the series, but he was dropped to the bench for the third and left out of the matchday squad entirely for the fourth clash in Baltimore, USA.

Read was emphatic about Holland’s value. “I think Holland is a starting lock for us. He’s, at the moment, our best lock. That’s what I’m seeing,” said Read. “So, whether they were resting him or not, I don’t know what the reasons were. But to me, he’s our best lock right now. So, I can’t explain that one.”

Marshall suggested that the coaching staff prioritised versatility when naming the bench, which counted against Holland. “I think when you look at the dynamic of the bench, so what they were looking at, I guess, he’s lock-specific,” he explained. “So is Josh Lord, so is Sam Darry. Whereas the others, like, you could put Scooter (Scott Barrett) on the side (of the scrum). Obviously, Tupou Vaa’i can go both (lock and flanker positions).”

Marshall noted that the All Blacks did not name a specialist lock on the bench at the weekend. “If people didn’t notice, they picked (Anton) Segner and (Shannon) Frizell. Because they can move those components around. So I think first and foremost, if they had the conversation, and I believe it was a very debated one amongst the coaches and selectors about Fabian. They didn’t go for him on the bench.”

Read disagreed strongly. “It makes no sense to me. Because this guy’s a world-class player. He’s shown it. Yes, he’s been out for a long time (after injury), but he’s shown it against (the Springboks). He’s outstanding.”

Read also acknowledged that the lineout has struggled this year, but he believes Holland belongs in the starting side. “It has struggled (the lineout). I’m unsure why, but it has struggled. So, we’ve been forced to the front a lot of the lineout, which I don’t mind. If we can win ball fast and get in and win it front, it’s fine. It’s the same as middle ball off-tempo. But Holland, he’s a lock, purely. And you need him playing out there, because he can get around the field.” He added that Holland, Scott Barrett and Tupou Vaa’i could form a world-class combination, and that “they just haven’t had the footy in that position just yet.”

Bench balance

Read suggested that a 6-2 split on the bench would allow Holland to make the matchday squad. “Yeah, it is (the 6-2 split), because then you can carry that lock and two loosies,” he said. Marshall was frustrated that the squad does not reflect that approach. “Well, f*ck me, they won’t do it, though, will they? I’m sorry, but why are they picking two wingers (on the bench)? Like, I get it. If you want to go 5-3, go 5-3. But don’t pick like for like. (Josh) Moorby and (Rieko) Ioane both play on the wing.”

Marshall argued that the bench could offer more tactical options. “You’re not getting anything out of not (picking) a (Timoci) Tavatavanawa, whoever it might be, or a Josh Jacomb and go, ‘You know what, mate? We didn’t want to start you, but if the things are going well in the Test’, which they were after we were up by 40 points, ‘go on then’. But when you pick two wingers, that 5-3 split just doesn’t make sense to me. I’m baffled by that. I’d love to know what the thought process in that was.”

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *